If you have a local Titleist Rep., ask them to order one for you.  If not I know that there are tons of them on eBay that are brand new.  Best of luck!

Please tell us how that happened.(or Not) .....Maybe it will prevent someone else from doing the same...If it was from pulling it off the club is there a warranty?..good luck

My Edwin Watts has a ton of them. Try their website.

How did you break it? 

I broke it with the tail to the trunk of my car. Fortunately my driver wasn't in the cover, because I was using a different one that day. Lucky me. But it is completely cracked on the one side, so I would like to buy a new one.

Wow, that is not good!  Sounds like one of my typical days... lol